Pageviews from the past week

Sunday, 12 January 2014

Characterization; The Duke: critical commentary (Act I, scene III)


The Duke is fully conscious of the laxity of which he had been guilty in governing his country. He had allowed the strict statutes and the rigorous laws to become a dead letter, with the result that people had been taking more and more liberties, and been committing all kinds of offences and crimes. The Duke has a picturesque manner of speaking. He compares himself to an over-grown lion living in a cave, and not moving out to hunt his prey but inviting animals to visit him in his den so that he might feed upon them without having to take the trouble of going out. Then he compares himself to those foolish fathers who spare the rod and thus spoil the children. The Duke frankly admits that the conditions in the country have become so bad that his laws and decrees are now dead:
“And Liberty plucks Justice by the nose,
 The baby beats the nurse, and quite athwart
Goes all decorum.”
The Duke’s smiles and his sententious manner of speaking lend special interest to his speeches. The Duke assures Friar Thomas that he has not come to lead a scheduled life because of any disappointment in love which he may have suffered. He says that “the dribbling dart of love” cannot pierce a strong heart like his. However, as subsequent events will slow, the Duke is certainly not proof against the arrows of Cupid.

Plot- Development: critical commentary (Act I, scene III)


The Duke now approaches a friar by the name of Thomas and seeks his permission to disguise himself as a friar and to live in the friar’s cell. The Duke explains to Friar Thomas why he wishes to assume this disguise. He tells Friar Thomas that his laxity in enforcing the laws had led to a great increase in crime and that, in order to check the growing evil, he had, for a time, transferred his powers and authority to Angelo. The Duke says that he would now like to go about in a friar’s disguise and observe how Angelo governs the country.

Pathos and comedy:Critical commentary (Act I, Scene II)

The plight of Claudio, who is under arrest for having made Juliet pregnant without having been able to marry her firs, certainly arouses our sympathy for him. He wins our sympathy because of his good intentions towards the wronged girl. He earnestly wanted to marry her but had not able to do so because her dowry has not being released by her relations. However, there is plenty of comedy too in this scene. The conversation between Mistress Overdone and others is very amusing. Lucio, on seeing her, says:

 “Behold, behold where Madam Mitigation comes!
 I have purchased as many diseases under her roof as come to-”. 

When Mistress Overdone complains that the new proclamation issued by Angelo is likely to result in her brothel being dismantled, and when she asks what would become if her, Pompey makes and amusing speech. He says:  
“Come: fear not you: good counselors lack no clients:
 though you change your place, you need not change your trade:
 I’ll be your tipster still; courage, there will be pity taken on you; you that having worn your eyes almost out in the service, you will be considered.”
Pompey means to say that Mistress Overdone has been plying her trade as a whore so long that the authorities will show due consideration to her, and that she should not therefore worry too much about her future, especially when he would continue to be her tapster (or pimp). Towards the close of this scene, Lucio makes a witty remark when he tells Claudio that Claudio’s head stands so insecure on his shoulders that even a milkmaid in love can blow it off with her sighs. Lucio is the kind of man who must say something funny even in a situation which means trouble for others.

Thursday, 9 January 2014

Characterization: Claudio; Lucio; and Angelo: Critical commentary (Act I, Scene II)


When we first meet Claudio, he is under arrest. As the Provost seems to be parading the arrested Claudio at a public place, Claudio makes a mild protest against being thus exhibited. The Provost thereupon explains that it is under orders from above that he is exhibiting him (Claudio) to the public while taking him to the prison, Claudio makes a generalization in which he blames men of authority for being callous towards those who have incurred their wrath: “Thus can the demi-god, Authority, Makes us pay down for our offence by weight.” He makes another generalization when Lucio asks him why he has been arrested. In this case he says that too much liberty always invites restraint, meaning that a man who enjoys too much freedom is likely to be put under restraint. When Lucio asks him whence comes this restraint, Claudio replies: “From too much liberty, my Lucio. Liberty, As surfeit, is the father of much fast; So every scope by the immoderate use Turns to restraint.” Here he speaks almost like a moralist, and he speaks in a sententious, pithy style. Claudio, is giving to Lucio an account of the events leading to his arrest, tells him that he had been sleeping with Juliet whom he regards truly as his wife even though he is not yet formally married to her. He gives Lucio the reason why the ritual of marriage between him and Juliet had not been gone through. He then goes on to inform Lucio that a drastic action has been taken against him by Angelo who is the new governor of the country and who is probing to be a tyrannical ruler. Claudio says that Angelo has revived a certain law which had long been in disuse and has condemned him to the maximum punishment permitted by that law. He then requests Lucio to convey his predicament to his sister Isabella. Claudio would like Isabella to use all her graces and her persuasive manner of speech to try to win a pardon for him from Angelo. Claudio’s comments on Angelo lead us to believe that Angelo is really asserting his authority with the maximum rigour. Lucio’s manner of speaking shows him to be a frivolous kind of person. In fact, Lucio too is a comic character, like Pompey and Mistress Overdone even though he belongs to a higher class of society.

Characterization: Pompey and Mistress Overdone: Critical commentary (Act I, Scene II)


Pompey and Mistress overdone are low class characters who are intended to provide comic elements in the play. Lucio, though a gentleman, is familiar with both of them because he is in the habit of frequenting Mistress Overdone’s brothel. By his association with such characters, Lucio degrades himself in our eyes. Even Claudio discredits himself in our eyes by his intimacy with Lucio who is a man of a dissolute character. Claudio is, however, far more respectable than Lucio.    

Contemporary allusions in this scene: Critical commentary (Act I, Scene II)

The opening scene in this scene contains a reference to the possibility of some short of settlement being reached between the King of Hungary on one hand and all the Dukes on the other hand. The speech seems to be an allusion to certain contemporary events. Perhaps the reference here is to King James’s negotiations for a settlement with Spain. Peace negotiations had been started in the autumn of 1603. In May 1604, a conference opened at Hampton Court, attended by delegates from Spain and Austrian Netherlands. A draft treaty was prepared in July; and in August 1604, James ratified it by oath. Between May and August 1604, therefore, his prescription of peace with Spain had become a matter of special public concern. In the opening dialogue of this scene Lucio’s companions express some anxiety at that approaching end to the war that had been going on. Their anxiety is due to the fact that many gentlemen, who had anticipated a profitable career as soldiers, would now have to remain out of work if the war came to an end. There is a contemporary allusion in Mistress Overdone’s anxiety. The following speech by her is noteworthy: “Thus, what with the war, what with the sweat, what with the gallows, and what with poverty, I am custom-shrunk.” Mistress Overdone’s complaints links a numbers of factors pertaining to the winter of 1603-04; the continuance of the war with Spain; the plague in London; the treasons, trials, and executions at Winchester in connection with the plots by Raleih and others; and the slackness of trade in the deserted capital (deserted because of the plague). Another topical allusion occurs in Pompey’s telling Mistress Overdone that the government has issued a proclamation according to which all house in the suburbs of Vienna must be plucked down. A proclamation dated the 16th September 1603 had actually been issued by the British government ordering the dismantling of houses and rooms in the suburbs of London as a precaution against the spread of the plague by dissolute and idle persons. The measure, which was strictly enforced during the following months, led to numerous brothels and gambling houses being pulled down on the outskirts of the city (Though the action of the play has been set in Vienna, it is really London and England Which Shakespeare has in mind).